A Tsunami of Good Decisions

 

On a number of occasions, I have proposed the use of prediction markets for policy refinement and decisions, an idea that has long been studied in corporate and academic arenas. Unexpectedly, the startup set was busy turning the concept into just another gambling experience, rewarding influencers and insiders while fleecing the masses. But I want to revisit the idea in light of the mid-term “blue tsunami,” post “meteor-strike extinction event.” There are new opportunities to repair the damage of Trumpism as well as create policy structures to reestablish norms for government interaction.

First, populism and protectionism don’t solve problems, they exacerbate them and steamroll common sense. We see this in the broad use of tariffs and the inverted logic and emotional appeals that accompanied their application. Instead, this is a topic best left to technocrats finding solutions to political and economic problems, which means using tariffs in a narrow fashion to specifically address asymmetries in trade between nations. We are not going to correct Chinese industrial overcapacity by taxing Americans, for instance, but we can focus on those areas of trade imbalance that impact national security in a targeted fashion. Using tariffs to enhance industries like the automotive sector is fine on the surface, but it can also raise domestic product prices by eliminating or weakening competition. The technocrats can model all this and should offer politicians a collection of policy responses with well-articulated risk-reward matrixes.

There are a clutch of political meta-theories that are conjoined as epistemic democracy and that focus on how knowledge and information flow into democratic decision making. A fundamental question is how to choose who should do the governing in terms of solving problems of thriving?… Read the rest

Ensembles Against Abominables

It seems obvious to me that when we face existential threats we should make the best possible decisions. I do this with respect to investment decisions, as well. I don’t rely on “guts” or feelings or luck or hope or faith or hunches or trends. All of those ideas are proxies for some sense of incompleteness in our understanding of probabilities and future outcomes.

So how can we cope with those kinds of uncertainties given existential threats? The core methodology is based on ensembles of predictions. We don’t actually want to trust an expert per se, but want instead to trust a basket of expert opinions—an ensemble of predictions. Ideally, those experts who have been more effective in the past should be given greater weight than those who have made poorer predictions. We most certainly should not rely on gut calls by abominable narcissists in what Chauncey Devega at Salon disturbingly characterizes as a “pathological kakistocracy.”

Investment decision-making takes exactly this form, when carried out rationally. Index funds adjust their security holdings in relationship to an index like the S&P 500. Since stock markets have risen since their inceptions with, of course, set backs along the way, an index is a reliable ensemble approach to growth. Ensembles smooth predictions and smooth out brittleness.

Ensemble methods are also core to predictive improvements in machine learning. While a single decision tree trained on data may overweight portions of the data set, an ensemble of trees (which we call a forest, of course) smoothes the decision making by having each tree become only a part of the final vote for a prediction. The training of the individual trees is based on a randomized subset of the data, allowing for specialization of stands of trees, but preserving overall effectiveness of the system.… Read the rest